who we are

Many residents are not aware of their ability to shop around for a better price, nor do they want to take the time to contact every insurance company to receive quotes. At Keyes Insurance, we handle that burden for you. With our knowledge of the insurance market, we can provide you with an evaluation of the coverages and prices that are available from a variety of high quality insurance carriers. Our agency strives to find the best policy at the best price, with the most appropriate insurance company, to match your needs.

In addition to providing competitive solutions we also offer ongoing service by allocating customer service representatives to each policy to continuously monitor its competitiveness and security. At Keyes Insurance, we are committed to providing quality insurance solutions by building on thirty plus years of observing the insurance market at the highest level.


Save money
Client support
Quality service


We are committed to providing high quality insurance solutions - building on over thirty years of experience in the insurance industry.


To provide the people of Florida with the best policy at the best price from the insurance company that best matches their needs. To focus on customer service, integrity, cost effectiveness, and secur…

Ryan Papy is the President of Keyes Insurance and a founder of Tom Gallagher Insurance. He has over a decade of experience in the management and insurance industry. He specializes in identifying and negotiating insurance carrier products that are competitive and reliable for all insureds. In addition, Ryan specializes in...

Ryan Papy President

As General Counsel and Chief Financial Officer at Keyes Insurance, Jennifer is responsible for overseeing all legal and financial operations within the Agency. Prior to working for Keyes Insurance, Jennifer was a litigation Associate at Ferrell Law, and, prior to that, an Associate at Papy, Weissenborn, Vraspir, & Puga, specializing...

Jennifer Papy Chief Financial Officer

Tom Gallagher, one of the Founders of Tom Gallagher Insurance, has spent over 30 years serving the public in the State of Florida and has witnessed the problems citizens face in the insurance market. Since his retirement from public office, he has resolved to provide the people of Florida with...

Tom Gallagher Chairman

Nic is one of the founding principles of Keyes Insurance. With 12 years of experience in the insurance industry, Nic has the breadth of knowledge and market relationships necessary to best serve our clients. Currently, Nic serves as the Chief Operating Officer (C.O.O.) for the firm, where he leads a...

Nic Varsi Chief Operating Office

Daisy Tosado is the Customer Relations Manager at Keyes Insurance. She has over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry. Daisy has experience in claims, agency services, customer relations and employee management.

Daisy Tosado Customer Relations Manager

Keith Saunders is the Director of the Employee Benefits Division at Keyes Insurance and is tasked with the responsibility of strategic planning, client relations, overseeing CSR development, and helping build tailor-made benefits programs for each customer. Keith graduated with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from the University of...

Keith Saunders VP Director of Health

Patrick Puertas directs the marketing and servicing process of all Commercial clientele. He has dedicated himself to increasing business production while maintaining the personal relationships with each of his clients. Patrick has become a dependable source of customer satisfaction and product delivery for business owners.

Patrick Puertas VP Commercial Accounts Manager

Ana Castro has over 10 years of experience in the Insurance Industry, she joined the company as a customer service representative and later joined the sales department. Ana is responsible for establishing and maintaining relationships with Realtors, Loan Officers, and Clients by winning their trust and finding them competitive rates...

Ana Castro Account Specialist

Jennifer Ruiz has over 14 years of experience in the Insurance Industry. She has been with the company since 2012 where she started as a policy processor and later joined the sales department where she’s distinguished herself among her peers. In addition, she has been able to gain the trust...

Jennifer Ruiz Account Specialist

Carolyn Bonilla has over 10 years of experience in the insurance business. She started from a very young age at Gallagher Property & Casualty where she started learning the business from the ground up. Here she mastered skills of efficiency, organization, and responsiveness. Carolyn's area of expertise is in the...

Carolyn Bonilla Account Specialist
Sign Up for our Newsletter